"The Reformer was probably unique in Scottish journalism — its violent personal attacks on prominent public men — its satirical notes on the peculiarities and angularities of quiet and inoffensive citizens, who were easily recognized through the thin veil of anonymity thrown over them — even the very family circle was invaded — and to many the Reformer became intolerable and overlooked on as a nuisance to be put down.” “Now, we tell the lawyers, stop a little and we'll give you something worth stopping the Reformer for. Let them look out for the next number. We pledge ourselves to shiver their reputation lo atoms by telling the Truth.' Even the threat of 'giving wood engravings of not a few of them, in proper attitudes', did not save the persecuted Reformer at this time. After several months' suspension, however, it re-appeared” (Cowan).